Not the Lun Yu: The Chu Script Bamboo Slip Manuscript, Zigao, and the Nature of Early Confucianism

Sarah Allen
Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, 2009 vol. 71 pp. 115--151
DOI: DOI: 10.1017/S0041977X0900007X
Abstract:

This article includes a line-by-line translation and textual analysis of the

Warring States period Chu script bamboo slip manuscript, Zigao 子羔.

It argues that the manuscript differs from the transmitted Confucian tradition,

but would have been considered a ru (Confucian) text.

Unusual features include: (1) The disciple is Zigao, who is described negatively

in the Lun yu. (2) The term tian zi天子, son-of-sky/heavenis used

literally, to refer to the divinely conceived progenitors of the three royal

lineages. (3) The term san wang, three kings, refers to these progenitors

rather than the founding rulers. (4) Confucius advocates abdication. (5)

The progenitors of the dynastic lineages, rather than the founding rulers,

are juxtaposed to Shun , who received the rule from Yao because of

his merit. A Chinese edition, with direct transcriptions and alternative

readings of the Chu script graphs, is appended.